longer.blue

Here's 15 Reasons Why the "SAVE America Act" is Nothing More Than VOTER SUPPRESSION. 1. Mass Disenfranchisement of Eligible Citizens: More than 21 million Americans lack ready access to the required documents (passport or certified birth certificate). These are fully legal voters who could simply be locked out of registering under the new rules. 2. It Functions as a Poll Tax: Because passports and similarly costly documents are not available for free, requiring them to register to vote would function like a modern-day poll tax, echoing the fees Southern states once used to keep Black citizens from the ballot before the Voting Rights Act of 1965. A passport costs at least $165 plus photos, and getting an official certified birth certificate can cost up to $100. The poll tax was outlawed for federal elections by the 24th Amendment in 1964. 3. No Fee Waivers or Expidited Process: There is no provision for expedited or urgent processing for voter registration purposes, nor are application fees waived. Making matters worse, the State Department has cut its passport office in half and removed the ability to submit applications at local libraries, meaning physically going to an official office — which for many would mean traveling hundreds of miles. 4. The Married Women Name-Mismatch Problem: An estimated 69 million American women and 4 million men do not have a birth certificate that matches their current legal name. The bill requires voters who don't have a passport to present a birth certificate that matches the name on their REAL ID or driver's license — which married women who took their spouse's name simply cannot do. They may have to show a birth certificate, plus a marriage certificate, plus a photo ID — all linked together — creating a multi-document, multi-cost burden that other voters don't face. Exactly what supplementary documents would be accepted, and how consistently, is not spelled out in the bill, raising fears of uneven enforcement across jurisdictions. 5. Stricter ID Than Any State Currently Requires: The act would implement a national voter ID requirement more burdensome than almost every single state voter ID law currently in effect. Specifically, the bill prohibits the use of student IDs even from state universities, and accepts tribal IDs only with an expiration date, even though many tribal IDs do not contain one. Military ID cards are listed as qualifying documents, but must be accompanied by a military record of service showing the person's birthplace was in the U.S. — a requirement the standard DD214 discharge form does not currently fulfill. 6. REAL ID Doesn't Even Qualify: REAL IDs generally don't demonstrate proof of citizenship, and similarly, state-issued IDs can only be used if they include proof of citizenship — which most states do not include. This means the ID that millions of Americans obtained specifically to comply with federal requirements won't be enough under this bill. 7. Eliminates Convenient Voter Registration Methods: In 2022, more than seven million Americans registered to vote by mail, and almost 11 million registered online. The bill would severely threaten mail registration and require online systems to be completely overhauled. Campaign Legal Center Only 6% of voters currently register in person at an elections office — meaning the in-person requirement would be a dramatic and disruptive change for the vast majority of Americans. 8. Re-Registration Triggered by Ordinary Life Events: The bill would affect already-registered voters too. Any time someone updates their registration — if they change their address or political party — they would need to provide these citizenship documents all over again. This means moving, getting married, or switching parties would each trigger a new documentation requirement. 9. Error-Prone Voter Purges: The act mandates that states conduct frequent voter purges based on faulty data, a practice that removes registered voters from the rolls. A precedent already exists: in 2018, a federal judge struck down Kansas' proof-of-citizenship law after it was shown that more than 30,000 voter applications — about 12% of new registrations — were suspended or cancelled illegally. 10. Federal Seizure of Sensitive Voter Data: Every state would be forced to submit its voter rolls to DHS for comparison against the agency's flawed citizenship database, with no restrictions on what the federal government can do with that sensitive data once received. This is particularly alarming given that the administration previously conceded that DOGE team members agreed to turn over state voter rolls to an outside advocacy group seeking to find evidence of voter fraud and overturn election results. 11. Criminal Penalties for Election Workers: Election workers could face up to five years in prison for helping someone register without the correct documents, even if that person turns out to be a citizen. There is already a high turnover rate in election offices due to threats and harassment, and the additional legal risk could exacerbate that further. 12. No Implementation Timeline or Funding: The SAVE Act does not provide any money to help states and local governments implement the changes or promote them to voters. For most provisions, the bill contains no phase-in period, meaning its documentary proof-of-citizenship mandate would apply immediately and be in place for the 2026 midterm elections. 13. Solving a Near-Nonexistent Problem: Even the Heritage Foundation has uncovered just 100 instances of noncitizen voter fraud since 2000, out of roughly 1.5 billion ballots cast in federal elections — and there is no evidence noncitizen voting has ever affected the outcome of any election. The bill imposes sweeping costs on tens of millions of eligible voters to address what amounts to a statistically invisible problem. 14. Disproportionate Economic Impact: People with lower incomes or less education are far less likely to have a valid passport or the means to obtain one -meaning the financial and logistical burdens of this bill fall hardest on communities that have historically already faced the greatest barriers to voting. 15. End Mail Voting: Trump has repeatedly pushed to expand the legislation to end most mail-in voting, which would affect 36 states and D.C. that currently allow no-excuse mail voting or conduct elections entirely by mail. Taken together, critics argue the SAVE America Act layers financial costs, bureaucratic hurdles, strict new ID rules, and criminal penalties on top of a registration system that already legally requires citizenship attestation — all to address a problem that evidence consistently shows is vanishingly rare.