Richard Holway
Richard Holway
11/17/2026, 8:52:39 PM

Sweeping the Suitors from the House: Post-election Thoughts on Christopher Nolan's “Odyssey” and “Zeus's law” Christopher Nolan has rightly been criticized for confusing ancient Greek xenia, which prescribes the proper conduct of guest and host, with the Christian Golden Rule, and for representing his Christianized xenia as “Zeus's law,” a phrase which connotes something broader—and more political—than either Greek xenia or Nolan’s Christianized rendering of it. But there is more to be said. A concept of right order which could properly be termed “Zeus’s law” is in fact central to both the epic and Nolan’s adaptation of it. Audiences’ recognition of its centrality may help to account for the astonishing level of interest and box office success that the movie has enjoyed. The Odyssey is not simply a tale of a warrior’s safe return home from war, a nostos. It is the story of a homecoming which requires ousting a ruling clique that has no respect for other human beings or their rights, and restoring an inclusive order, based on mutual care and respect, to a household and polity that have been overrun by arrogant usurpers. (Contemporary resonances, anyone?) The suitors are terrible house guests. They scheme to replace Odysseus in Penelope's bed and on the throne of Ithaka, and to assassinate their son Telemachos—plundering Odysseus’s flocks and wine cellar in the meantime. The suitors’ trampling of the rights of Odysseus, his family, and the citizens of Ithaka violate not just apolitical xenia but fundamental notions of right order (themis) that are inherently political. The suitors’ unchecked arrogance, and the passivity of Ithaka’s citizens in the face of their abuses, constitute a political malaise which is due to the long absence of Ithaka’s capable, caring, and just king, Odysseus. The Odyssey’s narrative of how oppressive arrogation of power provokes opposition, which employs superior cunning and political wisdom (metis) to overthrow a regime that violates fundamental rights and establish a just regime (themis) in its place, belongs to the tradition of the Hesiod’s Theogony. In Hesiod’s poem, a tyrannical Kronos and his cronies (family members all), trample the rights of everyone else, including, fatally for him, Kronos’ wise and devious wife, Rheia, and their son, Zeus. After deposing Kronos and his sibs and being elected king of the gods by his fellow Olympians, Zeus ingests the goddess Metis (cunning, wisdom) and marries Themis (right order). With her Zeus fathers Dike (justice), Eunomia (lawfulness), and Eirene (peace). In place of oppressive rule by a family clique, Zeus offers the promise of a just, lawful, and peaceful order, in which all who contribute to establishing, sustaining, and defending it have honored places. The familial and political order of Ithaka, which Odysseus, Penelope, Telemachos, and their allies—guided by Athena—restore in Homer’s Odyssey, is a direct descendant of the just, lawful, and inclusive regime which Zeus and his siblings and allies establish after overthrowing tyrannical Kronos and his siblings in Hesiod’s Theogony. Far from being an anachronistic Christianized fabrication then, Christopher Nolan's term “Zeus’ law” comes closer to the central concerns of both the Odyssey and his own movie than either Nolan or his critics seem to realize. It cues the audience to recognize the centrality to the movie of what might justly be termed “Zeus’s law,” established by ousting usurpers who have no respect for the rights of others. The centrality of this theme to epic and movie alike may help to explain the tremendous appeal in 2026 of Nolan's cinematic adaptation of a three-thousand-year-old poem. A final thought: if even Achilles in the Iliad can regret causing grief to the Trojan king Priam by killing his sons, a feat for which Achilles wins immortal glory, why cannot Athena’s favorite, resourceful (polumetis) Odysseus, regret his role in unleashing the barbarity of the Greek sack of Troy, which wins him immortal renown? The Greek rampage culminates in the desecration of the temple of Odysseus’s divine patroness, the daughter of Zeus and Metis, Athena, who harries the homecomings of the offending Greeks in reprisal. There’s nothing Christian or un-Greek about these regrets of Achilles or (Nolan surmises) Odysseus.

Want to write longer posts on Bluesky?

Create your own extended posts and share them seamlessly on Bluesky.

Create Your Post

This is a free tool. If you find it useful, please consider a donation to keep it alive! 💙

You can find the coffee icon in the bottom right corner.